Twelve Atlantic Coast Conference football players earned at least one All-America team recognition from either the Walter Camp Football Foundation, Associated Press, Football Writers Association of America, American Football Coaches Association or Sporting News this season.  

Clemson led the way with four players named to an All-America team, including unanimous first-team selection Isaiah Simmons at linebacker and consensus first-team pick John Simpson at offensive guard.  Running back Travis Etienne was named second-team All-America on all five teams and safety Tanner Muse was a third-team AP selection.

Pitt defensive tackle Jaylen Twyman was named second team on four different teams, including Walter Camp, AP, Sporting New and FWAA.  Virginia kick returner Joe Reed picked up All-America honors from Walter Camp (first team), Sporting News (second team) and FWAA (second team). Miami defensive end Gregory Rousseau, Syracuse punter Sterling Hofrichter and Wake Forest place-kicker Nick Sciba were named to two All-America teams.

2019 ACC Football All-Americans
(The NCAA recognizes five outlets to determine its consensus All-Americans, including the Walter Camp Football Foundation, The Associated Press, the Football Writers Association of America and the American Football Coaches Association and Sporting News)

AJ Dillon, RB, Boston College
• Associated Press, third team

Travis Etienne, RB, Clemson
• Walter Camp, second team
• Associated Press, second team
• The Sporting News, second team
• AFCA, second team
• FWAA, second team

Tanner Muse, S, Clemson
• Associated Press, third team

Isaiah Simmons, LB, Clemson (unanimous All-America)
• Walter Camp, first team
• Associated Press, first team
• The Sporting News, first team
• AFCA, first team
• FWAA, first team

John Simpson, OG, Clemson (consensus All-America)
• Walter Camp, first team
• Associated Press, second team
• The Sporting News, first team
• AFCA, first team
• FWAA, first team

Noah Gray, TE, Duke
• Walter Camp, second team

Mekhi Becton, OT, Louisville
• The Sporting News, second team

Gregory Rousseau, DE, Miami
• The Sporting News, second team
• FWAA, second team

Jaylen Twyman, DT, Pitt
• Walter Camp, second team
• Associated Press, second team
• The Sporting News, second team
• FWAA, second team

Sterling Hofrichter, P, Syracuse
• Associated Press, third team
• FWAA, second team

Joe Reed, KR, Virginia
• Walter Camp, first team
• The Sporting News, second team
• FWAA, first team

Nick Sciba, PK, Wake Forest
• Associated Press, third team
• FWAA, second team